The Story of Thomas Swope's Unsolved Murder

If you were forwarded this email, click here to subscribe (it's free!)

​Read this story online | Sponsor this newsletter | Shop 📸

Thomas Hunton Swope was a highly influential figure in Kansas City's history, renowned for his success as a real estate developer and philanthropist. Born in Kentucky in 1827, Swope graduated from Yale University and ventured west to the Kansas Territory in 1855. At the age of 28, he became involved in decision-making and quickly amassed wealth through shrewd investments in downtown real estate.

Known to be mild-mannered and frugal, Swope lived for most of his life as a bachelor. It wasn't until later in life that he moved into his brother's grand red brick castle in Independence, where he resided with his sister-in-law and their seven nieces and nephews. From that household, Swope commuted daily to his downtown Kansas City office in the New England Building.

Despite being a lifelong bachelor, Swope's later days were consumed with thoughts of how best to distribute his wealth. His real estate alone was valued at three and a half million dollars (over $100M in 2023 dollars). Unfortunately, Swope fell under the influence of Dr. Bennett Clark Hyde, who had married one of his young nieces. Dr. Hyde was regarded with suspicion by some as a potential gold-digger.

Tragedy struck on October 3, 1909, when Swope died suddenly at the age of 81 in his sister-in-law's home. Dr. Hyde was present during his final moments, and a brief and violent illness preceded Swope's passing. Following his death, Swope's body lay in state at the Public Library, where thousands paid their respects. However, as a tomb was being prepared in Swope Park according to his wishes, his body temporarily resided in a holding vault.

Three months after Swope's death, Dr. Hyde, his nephew-in-law, came under suspicion in connection with a plot for money built around a string of mysterious deaths in the Swope family. The accusation was based on evidence that Dr. Hyde had recently acquired cyanide capsules and typhoid cultures. Swope's body was exhumed, and an autopsy revealed traces of a convulsive and paralyzing poison.

The trial of Dr. Bennett Clark Hyde became one of the most notorious in Kansas City's history. Strong evidence was presented, including the purchase of cyanide capsules, testimonies that Hyde had given a pill to Swope before his death, and the acquisition of typhoid samples before the outbreak of the disease. Nonetheless, the guilty verdict was eventually overturned by the Missouri Supreme Court.

Subsequent trials ended in a mistrial and a hung jury, leading to the dropping of all charges against Hyde in 1914. The case remained unresolved, leaving the public to speculate about what truly happened in the Swope mansion (pictured above) in 1909. The trials had a lasting impact on Hyde's life, as he faced public suspicion and had his career ruined. His wife eventually divorced him, and Hyde died in 1934 without ever confessing to the crimes attributed to him.

In 1918, almost nine years after his death, Thomas Hunton Swope was finally laid to rest in Swope Park. A Greek temple of white granite, guarded by stone lions, was erected to honor his memory. Today, Swope Park stands as a testament to his philanthropy and his significant contributions to the city of Kansas City.

Learn more about the murder of Thomas Swope: KCUR // KC History // Murder in Independence (video)​

Want to learn more about the names from around Kansas City? Ever walked down a Kansas City street and wondered about who it's named after? Embark on a 12-week journey with "Streets & Stories", with a new historical biography delivered straight to your inbox every week from KC Yesterday! In this course, you'll learn about: John Bristow Wornall Seth Edmund Ward Dr. Benoist Troost William Gregory Robert Gillham Thomas Swope William Strang ...and many more! Each week you'll dive into the captivating stories of these historical figures, discovering the pioneers that shaped our city. At the end of the course, you'll be an expert on the iconic streets and boulevards that connect our city. Sign up today and don't miss this chance to deepen your connection with Kansas City's heritage!​ 📖 Streets & Stories

This Week's Featured Home

5439 Norwood St, Fairway, KS 66205​
Built 1940 · $1,299,000
Listing/Photos Courtesy - Paige Moroney, Coldwell Banker Regan Realtors

The Weekly Featured Home is in partnership with KC Daily - the best news in Kansas City every weekday morning, for free.